I had some great info about this from a Major Gifts class I took from the Lilly school of philanthropy, as well as some great tips from other MGOs I know. Here are some options. Pick the best 3-5 metrics so you're not overwhelmed and go with them.
I encourage you to read the following excellent articles:
Major Gift Metrics
Evalutating MGO performance
Discussion moved to RENXT Community. Thanks!
@Faith Murray those are some great suggestions!
It may or may not be helpful, but I had an experience where major gift officer goals were - in part - based on Pledges and outright gifts. We had an MGO that was quite good at booking pledges, but pretty terrible about getting the payments. Our cash flow was not what was expected.
Pledge fulfillment can be based on a variety of factors, but the data showed an issue, and I encouraged leadership to look in to it.
Karen